Awarding Honorary Doctorates: Criteria and Controversies

Honorary doctorates have always been esteemed and a validated accreditation of a person’s remarkable contributions to business, science, society, or culture. Honorary degrees are awarded as a sign of appreciation as opposed to traditional doctorates that are obtained after years of study and research.  This honor is given by universities all over the world. Although the practice also questions its standards and the associated controversies.  Examining the nature of the honorary doctorates degree award reveals both its ongoing value and the difficulties and controversies it faces today. Nevertheless, an honorary doctorate degree is often seen as a symbol of distinction but the way it is awarded is not without discussions. This makes it essential to explore the criteria behind these awards and the controversies that continue to maintain their credibility in academic and public connections

What is a Honorary Doctorates ?

An Honorary Doctorate Degree is not an academic credential in the traditional sense. Instead, it is an accreditation of actual contributions in areas such as science, politics, social service, philanthropy, or business innovation. The honorary doctorate award reflects society’s valuation of individuals whose influence reaches far beyond the academic sphere. It does not permit beneficiaries to teach or hold academic posts; the doctorate awarded acts as a conceptual bridge between knowledge and societal contribution.

Case in point, when a university awards honorary doctorates, it publicly cooperates with the honoree’s values and achievements. The cooperation boosts the positive image of both parties and underlines the belief that real-world accomplishments can be as persuasive as academic ones.

Criteria for Awarding Honorary Degrees

Different institutions may follow slightly varied approaches, but the criteria for a doctorate awarded in honorary form often include:

1. Prominent success – Individuals must demonstrate extraordinary and impressive accomplishments in their chosen field.

2. Ethical Conduct – Candidates should embody high moral and ethical standards.

3. Global or National Impact – Their work should benefit society at large, transcending personal or commercial interests.

4. Alignment and Association with University Values – Universities select honorees whose lives reflect their mission and vision.

5. Diversity of Recognition – Many institutions aim to widen the scope for which an honorary doctorate degree award is conferred, ensuring representation across business, science, arts, and humanitarian work.

At Dunster Business School Switzerland, for instance, honorees are examined and evaluated for contributions to business innovation and community development before being awarded Honorary Doctorate status. Likewise, the Florida University of Science and Management confers the honorary Doctorate Degree on visionaries in science, technology, and education who inspire future leaders.

Historical Context of Honorary Degrees

The protocol of endowing an honorary doctorate degree dates back to the 15th century, with Oxford University among the first to present such an honor. Primarily meant to recognize exceptional scholars or benefactors, the practice spread across Europe and eventually the world. In the long run, this award evolved from a purely academic gesture into a cultural and societal acknowledgment. Universities began granting them both to intellectuals and also to leaders in politics, business, and the arts.

The historical use of the doctorate articulates academia’s acknowledgment of achievements that extend beyond research and teaching. Today, this tradition reflects how universities remain connected to broader global contributions.

Recent Examples of Honorary Doctorate Degree Awards

Lately, the honorary doctorate degree has been granted to a wide range of global influencers:

• In 2024, Oprah Winfrey was awarded an honorary doctorate for her philanthropic leadership and promotion of education.

• Elon Musk received a doctorate awarded in recognition of his contributions to renewable energy and space exploration.

• The Florida University of Science and Management recently granted an honorary doctorate degree award to Nobel laureate Jennifer Doudna for her groundbreaking CRISPR research.

• Dunster Business School, Switzerland, presented an Awarded Honorary Doctorate to Ananya Sharma for her commendable work in sustainable business entrepreneurship.

• In India, Amitabh Bachchan was given a doctorate awarded for his everlasting influence on cinema and charitable causes.

These examples exemplify how the honor outshines academic boundaries, celebrating achievements in various fields.

Controversies Surrounding Honorary Doctorates

Many critics and analysts claim that the selection process can sometimes undermine the credibility of the award.

1. Political Agendas – Universities are sometimes answerable for granting honors to individuals based on political influence rather than credibility.

2. Celebrity Sponsorship – The practice of awarding entertainers or celebrities with not so much academic contribution has raised suspicion.

3. Scandals and Withdrawals – Some institutions have been forced to abolish an awarded honorary doctorate due to the recipient’s later Malpractice.

4. Financial Donations – Concerns arise when large donors receive an honorary doctorate degree award, creating suspicions of bias.

Well-documented controversies include degrees awarded to figures like Robert Mugabe, which later backlash against other awards to controversial business leaders. Such cases reiterate the need for universities to exercise due diligence before a doctorate award is finalized.

Why Honorary Degrees Still Matter?

While controversies persist, the honorary doctorate degree remains of high value. It validates their lifetime achievements and inspires others to follow their path. For institutions, it strengthens global networks and builds prestige. Each time a university has awarded an honorary doctorate, the news has captured media attention. Hence, reinforcing the credibility of the institution.

When a doctorate award is given responsibly, it not only honors the recipient but also highlights the university’s values. This balance of recognition and responsibility ensures the honorary doctorate degree award continues to be meaningful.

Dunster Business School Switzerland: A Case Study

Fairly celebrated for its excellence in business education, Dunster Business School Switzerland has honored leaders who illustrate innovation, ethics, and sustainability. By granting an awarded honorary doctorate, the school acknowledges individuals making a positive impact on worldwide business practices. Their selection process emphasizes transparency and credibility. This ensures that every honorary doctorate degree award reflects both institutional integrity and global relevance.

One of their exceptional recognitions, Ananya Sharma, outshines sustainable entrepreneurship, building businesses that uplift communities worldwide. Through such honors, Dunster demonstrates how this Honorary Degree can engage contributions that go beyond profit-making.

Florida Institute of Science and Management: Recognizing Global Leaders

The Florida University of Science and Management take delight in its structured approach to the Honorary Doctorate Degree Award. The management’s key focus lies in recognizing achievements in science, innovation, and humanitarian efforts. Every doctorate awarded by this university undergoes a definitive and impactful process to ensure credibility and fairness.

In recent years, their decisions to honor Nobel Prize winners, climate activists have highlighted the value of the awarded honorary doctorate. These awards inspire students and reinforce the university’s role in supporting global progress.

The Future of Honorary Degrees

To streamline the future, we can predict that the honorary doctorate degree may increasingly be used to recognize leaders. Here, they will be handling global issues such as climate change, poverty, and digital transformation. Institutions like Dunster Business School Switzerland and Florida University of Science and Management are already leading in this direction, conferring the honorary doctorate degree award on impactful individuals whose influence is shaping the future and the ones leading it. In this way, every doctorate awarded becomes not just an academic honor but also a public statement of alignment with worldwide values.

Conclusion

The honorary doctorate degree remains a powerful recognition of excellence, making up the deficit between academia and real-world achievement. While controversies will obviously stay intact, careful and transparent processes help preserve the credibility of this honor. By granting the honorary doctorate degree award to individuals of true merit, universities like Dunster Business School Switzerland and Florida University of Science and Management continue to maintain their worthy prestige. Each doctorate awarded is a tribute to human achievement, academic values, and the perpetual link between knowledge and societal progress.

Recommended Reads

1. Top 8 Honorary Doctorate Degrees in UAE
2. What is an Honorary Doctorate(Honoris Causa)?
3. Types of Honorary Doctorates: D.Litt., D.Div., DHL & More
4. Truth Behind the Henry Harvin Certificate Value

FAQs